Concert Review: Porcupine Tree in New York City 10/13/07

Porcupine Tree

I don’t really know how to start so I’ll dive right in to the concert review. After a little background!

Porcupine Tree were last here in May and I was fortunate enough to catch them back then. Fear of a Blank Planet had just been released and the band all of it. Non-stop. Now, five months down the line, the band have released a new EP titled Nil Recurring and are back on tour. The setlist for this tour has been changed somewhat to accommodate the new material and also sees the return of some old fan favorites. The setlist for my show is featured at the end of post, annotated to indicate album!

So for a change, the show kicked off with What Happens Now? from the new EP. The mood was set and PT were on their way. Boy, did they rock the house! Steven Wilson was in a good mood throughout the concert and the crowd was fantastic. Hearing Dark Matter live was exhilarating! Anesthetize followed a new song, Cheating the Polygraph and some brief chatter from SW. He said, “Some of these new songs are hard to play you know! But this next one’s easy. It’s only 17 minutes long!” That cracked me up.

Towards the end of the main set, SW said, “We’re now going to play the last two songs” to which the crowd responded with a resounding “NOOOOOO.” With a grin on his face, SW shot back, “What do mean NO? We’re going to play the last two songs off the new record, not the last two for the night!” That was a signal for them to indeed play the last two tracks off FoaBP, Way Out of Here and Sleep Together. Both kicked some major ass and Sleep Together was great as a set closer. But I kept waiting and waiting and Blackest Eyes never came.

When the guys came back for an encore, SW said they would have to learn new songs when they return the next time. And then they kicked off the encore with Blackest Eyes. HELL YEAH!!! PT followed up my favorite with Even Less and Halo! What an encore! Sure, they didn’t play Trains, but I got to hear that last time around. This time, I got three tracks off the new EP, The Sound of Muzak, Even Less, Dark Matter, and A Smart Kid!!!

To sum it up, another great show by one of my favorite bands. The sound was probably better at the show in May but this one wasn’t too far behind in terms of quality and sheer energy. I hope they return soon with new songs and maybe play a larger venue! SW said, “We come here every six months but you guys still show up.” We will continue to show up to hear you guys play live!

Oh yeah, the opening band was Head>>Fake Sound System, a side project by Doug Wimbish and Will Calhoun of Living Color. Nothing special but Doug Wimbish was doing some real crazy shit with his bass. It was just the two of them, one on bass, one on drums, with a laptop providing some extra tunes to help them out. They didn’t play for long and PT came on right around 9pm. They finished a few minutes before 11. Tight performance.

SETLIST:

What Happens Now? Nil Recurring EP
Fear of a Blank Planet Fear of a Blank Planet
The Sound of Muzak In Absentia
Lazarus Deadwing
Cheating the Polygraph Nil Recurring EP
Anesthetize Fear of a Blank Planet
Open Car Deadwing
Dark Matter Signify
Nil Recurring Nil Recurring EP
A Smart Kid Stupid Dream
Way Out of Here Fear of a Blank Planet
Sleep Together Fear of a Blank Planet

Encore:

Blackest Eyes In Absentia
Even Less Stupid Dream
Halo Deadwing


6 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Great review and awesome show by the looks of it. But where were Art Brut? :P

good review…you lucky bastard :P

Lucky you…
attending to two Porcupine Tree concerts in the same year.

Poets of the Fall are coming to India (IIT Kanpur) [in fact Asia for the first time] this month but there’s no chance for us (outsiders) to attend that concert.

Thanks a lot for this. I saw them both shows in Chicago this year, and am hitting the last concert on the tour in Atlanta, so I was curious how they would change the set list.

Still wish they would play ‘Arriving’ and ‘Start of Something Beautiful’, but looks like a solid list.

Great review! Thanks for putting up the set list, I’d been looking for that. I was at both the shows that you went to in New York City. In my opinion, the sound at the Nokia Theater was quite miserable and this concert was much better in terms of sound quality. I look forward to seeing them again in NYC soon.

The sound really depends on where you are in the venue. At Nokia, I was only a few feet from the stage center and sound was awesome. At the Beacon, I was in the eighth row from the stage and off to the left. I don’t think the sound at the Beacon was bad - just that Nokia felt somewhat better.

TrackBack URI

Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)